FacilityProof

Crestwood Care Center

Nursing Homes

1.0CMS overall rating
225 W Main Street, Shelby, OH 44875(419) 347-1266For profit
13/100
Concerning
CCN365284

Critical Red Flags

  • 4 severe (actual-harm or immediate-jeopardy) deficiencyies in the latest inspection.
  • CMS has denied Medicare/Medicaid payment for new admissions.
  • Lowest possible CMS overall rating (1 star).

Warnings

  • Staffing is below the state average (3.31 vs 3.7 nurse hours per resident per day).
  • 2 federal fines totaling $232,204.

CMS Rating Breakdown

Overall1.0
Health inspection2.0
Staffing3.0
Quality measures4.0

Star ratings are CMS's relative measure, not an absolute “best” claim. A 3-star facility is average. See our guide to reading the Five-Star rating.

Trust Verification Checklist

  • CMS certified & active
  • Overall rating 3+ stars
  • Staffing at/above state average
  • No severe deficiencies in latest survey
  • No recent enforcement penalty

Staffing Reality

3.31

Total nurse hrs / resident / day

0.45

RN hrs / resident / day

3.7

State average (total)

Below the state average by 0.4 hrs/resident/day.

Higher staffing is one of the strongest predictors of quality. Why staffing matters.

Inspection Deficiencies

62

Total deficiencies

4

Severe (actual harm / IJ)

March 25, 2025

Most recent survey

A few deficiencies per survey is normal; severity matters more than count. What deficiencies mean.

Enforcement History

2

Federal fines

$232,204

Total fine amount

1

Payment denials

Peer Comparison

1

This facility (stars)

3.2

State average (stars)

2

Nursing Homes in Shelby

13

FacilityProof trust score

Official CMS Record

We reproduce CMS data — always confirm the live record on Medicare's official Care Compare page.

View on Care Compare

Quick Facts

Type
Nursing Home
Ownership
For profit
CCN
365284
City facilities
3

Location

Last updated (CMS): July 3, 2026

Nearby Nursing Homes